Haters May Cry: A Study of Nerd Rage

Haters May Cry: A Study of Nerd Rage
My thoughts on the Devil May Cry reboot.

I have seen some pretty bad cases of Nerd Rage in recent years; Michael Bay’s butchery of Transformers, The Amazing Spider-Man’s great divide, and more recently the insane reaction from fans when The Dark Knight Rises was not the best thing since sliced bread. This however, must take the cake.
Back when game developers Ninja Theory revealed that they were going to be ‘reinventing’ one of fellow developer Capcom’s most treasured franchises I knew what was coming… They were going to reboot Devil May Cry. At the time I could see the chain of events that would follow and unfortunately I was not far off from what transpired. Hard core fans of the series immediately rose up in protest of such an audacious decision, threatening wide scale boycotts and social media campaigns against Ninja Theory. Since the announcement the UK-based studio has been more or less been stripped by the internet, smeared with honey and thrown aside for trolls and haters to feed on. I genuinely feel for Ninja Theory as they knew they would be in a no-win situation when they undertook this task. If they opted to reboot the franchise they would be met with a tsunami of rage from reactionary fans, if they went ahead with the familiar then they would be slammed for being unoriginal.
Damned if you do, damned if you don’t…

So, rather than recycle stock character tropes and storylines Ninja Theory decided to go ahead with their reinvention in the face of massive opposition. Do I think that they made the right call? Hell yes!
The recent exhibition of “DMC”, the title of this reboot, at Gamescom 2012 has reaffirmed my faith in the developers and the daring direction they are taking this beleaguered franchise.

For those of you who do not know about the lore of the Devil May Cry universe I can provide a brief explanation. The series revolves around a self-styled ‘Demon Hunter’ called Dante, a rebellious maverick with a cocky attitude but a good heart. Dante is the son of Sparda, a legendary demon knight who rebelled and fought against his own kind for the sake of humanity. Dante and his twin brother Vergil lost their mother to an attack by demons when they were young and later ended up going their separate ways at an undisclosed time. Driven by a burning desire to avenge the death of his mother and to uphold his father’s legacy Dante ruthlessly hunts the spawn of the underworld that creep through to the human world whilst moonlighting as a private detective and mercenary through his shop the “Devil May Cry”.

The premise was solid, the story was great, and the action was stellar, but the series eventually tail span into absurdity and ran itself into the ground with its latest instalment “Devil May Cry 4”. While it was not a bad game Devil May Cry 4 was unable to plaster over the cracks in the narrative that were clearly starting to show, these characters had run their course and it was time for them to move on. Personally my main problem with the original series is that it got far too melodramatic and theatrical, something that I think got worse with each new title. Repetition was also a problem, there are only so many times one could listen to long-winded speeches about “The sons of Sparda” before they started skipping cut scenes and muting their TV’s. The settings of the games also got a bit weird; Dante could be fighting in the middle of a city street one minute and find himself in the middle of a jungle the next, where is the consistency there?

Then we get this trailer from Ninja Theory, this is what they are aiming for and frankly I am very impressed.

This trailer is what I hope has started winning people over to the new direction of the franchise, it is a setting well and truly cemented in our world. In this reinvented world Dante is a young repeat offender, orphaned after the death of his mother, who has been on the run from authorities for most of his life thus far. The authorities that are persecuting him turn out to be demons that have subtly enslaved the population of Limbo City, the game’s central setting. Numerous allusions to aspects of our real world are made in the story; Surveillance cameras implying an Orwellian-like regime, the “Raptor News Network” and it’s presenter bearing too much of a resemblance to FOX News and Bill O’Reilly to be a coincidence, and the mention of an oppressive banking system adding further relativity to the story. One could even make the connection between the masked narrator seen in the trailer and the infamous group “Anonymous”, which is a very anti-establishment group on the internet.

To make things even more interesting demonic forces are so prevalent in Limbo City that they are able to draw Dante into a twisted version of the city, something I feel echoes scenes from the movie “Constantine”. It looks fascinating and I think it is a great way to create environmental variety whilst not sacrificing plausibility in the process. Dante is drawn into helping a resistance movement known as “The Order”, a group wanting to overthrow the oppressive regime when he discovers that it is being led by his twin brother Vergil.

I feel there are a few reasons fans have had such bad cases of nerd rage over this reboot, and hardly any of them are valid. I feel the need to address the issue haters have the most, shame really because it is a feeble reason to hate on a game not even released yet.
“Dante looks like emo twilight spawn”
If you ask me he looks like a punk. His attire and features have clearly had influence from old-school British rock/punk music (Sex Pistols & Motorhead), which makes sense when you consider Ninja Theory is a UK-based developer. People need to stop this immature trend of branding everything with the iron of Twilight and realise there are more colours than black and white. Are fans really this upset about losing their white fair-haired pretty boy who himself would not look out-of-place on the set of a tween-romance movie? It’s sad, it’s really sad when the primary reason people end up hating a game prematurely purely because of a change in the way a character looks. It does not matter if the fans consider the character an icon, icons change – always have and always will.

I’ll finish with a great quote from a senior member of the development team that I feel every single hater and troll of this reboot needs to read.
“If it were sacrilege to change icons, we’d still be stuck with 60’s Batman,” argues Tameem Antoniades, creative director on the reboot. “Batman survived reinvention and is stronger and enduring as a result. Superman by comparison is tired and stuck in a past that holds little interest. Capcom felt it was time for a reinvention and came to us. So we have to honour that and take the risks we feel necessary to redefine Dante.”

The twisted version of Limbo City looks incredible.

Are haters really this shallow? For the love of god give this a go and see if you end up surprising yourself.

DMC is out on PlayStation 3 and Xbox360 early next year.



  1. This was a good read. I don’t know why so many people are afraid of change. Change can lead to bigger and better things, but everyone fight it no apparent reason. I look forward to jumping into the new world of DMC.

  2. This isn´t a study. Just a article with your opinion – your for DmC. So your calling the opposition for “nerds”.

    A real study would be objective and look DmC controversy from a pschological perspective. Something

    And considering they are using DMC brand and the character Dante (the character the people raging love) – i would say they have the right to complain.

    But DmC supporters like yourself have double standard. We can´t complain but you guys can…hypocrisy.

    And con

    1. In retrospect I might have picked a better title certainly.
      It never ceases to amaze me how severe knee-jerk and/or reactionary audiences, no matter the form of media, can be about the most simple things. I saw this happen with Star Trek, The Amazing Spider-Man, and most people seem to forget how angry audiences were when Batman Begins was in production.

      True, they (Ninja Theory) are using the brand and a few characters from previous titles but the brand is still the property of Capcom and therefore they have the right to wield their artistic license with it’s content.
      Capcom openly supports the direction this is going in.

      I would like to think I do not have double standards but my post might have come across as slightly condescending, if it did then I apologize. However, if I saw opponents of this reboot using a better argument than “Dante looks different, this game must burn in hell” or “The setting is wrong, there is no castles, underworld, etc” I might be more sympathetic to their views.
      “Hating” on an unreleased title entirely on it’s aesthetics is just plain silly and until I play the game myself and am (maybe) ultimately proven wrong I will stick to my view that this is the best call for the franchise.

      Thank you for the reply,
      Dale James

  3. A character is just a useless “posession” until fans make it valueable by liking it. This grants the owner of the character to use this for their own gain (marketing). And if the owner uses the character to market a other character – of course fans will be angry. Though a character is often considered valueable by the creator. In this case the creator of Dante is Hideki Kamiya and not Capcom. Point with this pharagraph: If your going to be so cheap and use a popular character (Dante) to attract buyers for a other game (DmC) by creating a version of it – then you better prepare for the consequences (unless your the creator of original character).

    Now…i believe DmC will be a ok game. I can only speak for myself, and it is that it´s looking very unappealing. Considering it´s using DMC material, the people behind DmC (Tameem and Capcom), the philosphy of Graphics over Gameplay (Ninja theory´s, and DmC´s priority), the fake “World is going to crush you” when all it is is a fake feeling to it AND other things that i can´t think of right now.

    Now i will explain to you a major ASPECT of why people is against DmC as a game. They don´t hate the idea of a spinoff game made by Ninja theory. They dislike DmC, and for good reasons. But let me repeat: if Ninja theory made a spiritual successor to DMC serie with the exact gameplay you see in DmC but with new story and character – people including MOST DMC fans would be open minded about it.

    Tameem Antoniades (cofounder of Ninja theory) who is leading DmC project on NT´s side has disrespected fans, Dante and Trish and more. He is a disrespectful, arrogant and ignorant douchebag who thinks that his OPINION is FACT.

    The concept of a reboot or retcon is that things change. Not that i like reboots – i think it´s cheap and cowardly approach to creating games.
    Despite the fact that reboots means things change (not limited to characters), Tameem Antoniades felt the need to defend why DmC character who´s name is Dante is changed compared to the real Dante after fans dislike of the character. Defending his company´s version of Dante in itself is nothing negative. But Tameem Antoniades defended his version of Dante by saying crap about real Dante. He said “Dante would get laughed out if he walked into a bar in Tokyo” and “What was cool 12 years ago is no longer cool”.

    His last statement may be partially true, but what is cool or not is subjective. What you consider cool may not be what i consider cool and vice versa. And furthermore Tameem Antoniades explained that one of DmC inspiration is Punk movement from 1970s, and that this inspiration has influenced his version of Dante. So his argument about “things stop being cool over time” is very contradicting when you realize he´s used a movement from over 40 years ago as inspiration for his character. But punk movement started in UK and i am sure in today´s modern society there is tons of punk looking individuals among british youths. But that goes to show you that what defines cool is different from person to person.

    And the first statement of how real Dante would get laughed out in a bar is really stupid. He´s taking a video game character and putting him into a real life modern setting as if that´s a valid argument for Dante being no longer cool. His company created a character named Monkey from Enslaved. Alex Garland (a collague of Tameem) shared with EDGE ONLINE in a interview that Tameem found Monkey beating up a helpless slave BAD ASS.
    So by Tameem´s own logic if we put Monkey into a real life setting in a bar – wouldn´t he get laughed out? Yes, he would…
    Though if you go by my logic i don´t think Dante, Monkey, Link from Legend of Zelda or most video game characters get laughed at. Instead people in a bar would look at them with a fascinating look like “What´s that?”.

    TO SUM UP:
    Tameem imposed his opinion of what is cool on fans, disrespected fans (and not only by imposing opionin) and disrespected Dante.

    And that is a PIECE of why people dislike DmC and keep hating on it.
    There are also valid arguments about the game itself. Such as Tameem described Limbo would do everything to kill you but in demo the walls are SLOWLY trying to kill you.
    The fact that the game is running on 30 fps could have negative effect on the gameplay smoothness.
    The fact that graphics (motion capture) is prioritized over innovating the gameplay. DmC gameplay seems liked recycled gameplay of DMC 1-4 combined with adapted to UNREAL ENGINE. In DMC 1(i believe) if you stood near a sealed/shutoff door the hand covering the door would try to grap you. That small feature in DMC 1 seems way more threatning than the “WORLD will kill you” concept with Limbo. Walking through a non threatning scripted part of a game sounds very boring. I find looking at the videos of it very boring too.

    If i was to critize the story of DmC from what i know of it:
    It seems like Tameem has taken three stories and mixed it into one. They live movie, V for Vendetta and DMC story.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: